Amateur Football Combination

Affiliated to the Amateur Football Alliance, London F.A., Middlesex F.A. and Surrey F.A.

Spirit of Football

Playing in the Spirit of Football, Promoting Fair Play and Respect for All

Is the Pitch Fit for Play? Guidance for Referees                                                  3G Pitches reminder                                                     London Old Boys Cup Trophies due for Return                                                       Peter Mills MBE                                                      AFA Refereeing Course                                                         Goffs Old Boys 1st XI withdrawn                                              Alex Grayburn unavailable                                                  Old Kolsassians Resignation                                               AFC Club Ratings to 17th December                                                    Andy Taylor Remembered                                             David Demeza Remembered                                                  Outstanding Subscriptions                                                    Wandgas - Charter Standard Community Award                                                  AFC at Christmas - no fixtures 24th and 31st December                                                     Club Referees                                                  AFC 1 Cambridge University 1                                                    Temple Bar withdrawal                                                    Old Camdenians                                                         AFC Rules - Maximum Three Substitutes                                                    Club Ratings to 22nd October 2011                                                  AFC 3 London Legal League 1                                                  Prams and Bicycles                                                  Harrowing Tale                                                     Player Registration Deadline                                                   AFC Representative Team - Get Involved                                                Alex Grayburn Away                                                  League Match Secretary Changes                                                     SMS Result Reporting This Season                                         AFC Player Registration 2011-12                                                    AFC Handbooks                                                AFC Constitution for 2011-12                                                  Match-Based Discipline 2011-12                                                   Match Day Reminders                                                  AFC New Club Officers Evening - Tuesday 27th September                                                   Spirit of Football/Respect Reminders for 2011-12                                               Members Services User Guides                                                  Updated Marking of Referees for 2011-12                                                     League Match Secretaries for 2011-12/Pitch Availability                                                   2011 Annual General Meeting Report                                                   2010-11 League Fines                                                  AFC Refereeing Feedback                                                  Revised AFC Constitution 2011-12                                                 AFC Preseason Fixture Bureau Open                                                  Match Based Discipline Handbook                                                   Laws of the Game Changes                                                  AFA Referee Training Courses - Chiswick, Fairlop, Carshalton, Wanstead, Winchmore Hill                                                   AFC Dinner Thanks                                                  6 South Trophy Withheld                                                  Spirit of Football Winners 2010-11 - Citigroup, Old Pauline, UCL Academicals                                                   Ken Elbourne Club Hospitality Award - Old Whitgiftians                                                    Ken Fletcher Club Development Award - Old Tenisonians                                                   McCarthy Refereeing Awards - Chris Beament, John Hayes, Jason Peters                                                    AFC Constitution 2011-12                                                  Final League Tables                                                  Final Club & Team Ratings                                                     Valuables and Cars                                                    Respect/Spirit of Football Reminders

Guidance for Marking Referees

Back to main Club Guidance Menu

 

All AFC clubs are required to adhere to the Football Association marking scheme with marks from 1-100, which was introduced in 2006.

The mark awarded by a club must be based on the referee’s overall performance, It is most important that the mark is awarded fairly and not based upon isolated incidents or previous games. The Referee’s performance should be determined by the table below which should act as a guide for the overall mark which should fall within the mark range for each standard of performance.

A mark of 91-100 would be regarded as 'excellent'. A mark between 71 and 80 would represent the standard expected.

 

Mark Range

Comment

100-86 The Referee demonstrated very accurate decision-making and controlled the game very well using management and communication skills effectively to add value to the game.
85-76 The Referee demonstrated accurate decision-making and controlled the game well using management and communication skills to contribute positively to the game.
75-61 The Referee demonstrated reasonably accurate decision-making and despite some shortcomings generally controlled the game well.
60 and below The Referee demonstrated shortcomings in the accuracy of decision- making and control which affected the game.

 

The Referee 

Notes

bullet

Club officials should use the full range of marks within each category to help distinguish between different performance levels, e.g. within the 85-76 category a mark of 84 indicates a better performance than a mark of 77.

bullet

While some Referees may have below average performances, there will usually have been some positive aspects of their performance, so extremely low marks should be very rare.

bullet

When club officials are marking a Referee, they should always look on the game as a whole and not isolated decisions. The result of the match should not influence the mark and disciplinary action should be judged objectively.

bullet

When a mark of 60 or less is awarded, an explanation must be provided to the Competition using the box provided on the marking form. The purpose of this is to assist Referees to improve their performance levels, so the comments should be as helpful as positive.

 

How to Decide on the Referee’s Mark

The following questions focus on the key areas of a referee’s performance. They are intended as an "aide memoire", are not necessarily comprehensive and need not be answered individually. It is, however, worth considering them before committing yourself to a mark for the referee.

 

CONTROL AND DECISION MAKING

bullet

How well did the Referee control the game?

bullet

Were the players’ actions recognized correctly?

bullet

Were the Laws applied correctly?

bullet

Were all incidents dealt with efficiently/effectively?

bullet

Were all the appropriate sanctions applied correctly?

bullet

Was the Referee always within reasonable distance of incidents?

bullet

Was the Referee well positioned to make critical decisions, especially in and around the penalty area?

bullet

Did the Referee understand the players’ positional intentions and keep out of the way accordingly?

bullet

Did the Referee demonstrate alertness and concentration throughout the game?

bullet

Did the Referee apply the use of the advantage to suit the mood and temperature of the game?

bullet

Was the Referee aware of the players’ attitude to advantage?

bullet

Did the Referee use the assistants effectively?

bullet

Did the officials work as a team, and did the Referee lead and manage them to the benefit of the game?

 

COMMUNICATION AND PLAYER MANAGEMENT

bullet

How well did the Referee communicate with the players during the game?

bullet

Did the Referee’s level of involvement/profile suit this particular game?

bullet

Did the Referee understand the players’ problems on the day – e.g. difficult ground/weather conditions?

bullet

Did the Referee respond to the changing pattern of play/mood of players?

bullet

Did the Referee demonstrate empathy for the game, allowing it to develop in accordance with the tempo of the game?

bullet

Was the Referee pro-active in controlling of the game?

bullet

Was the Referee’s authority asserted firmly without being officious?

bullet

Was the Referee confident and quick thinking?

bullet

Did the Referee appear unflustered and unhurried when making critical decisions?

bullet

Did the Referee permit undue questioning of decisions?

bullet

Did the Referee deal effectively with players crowding around after decisions/incidents?

bullet

Was effective player management in evidence?

bullet

Was the Referee’s body language confident and open at all times?

bullet

Did the pace of the game, the crowd or player pressure affect the Referee negatively?

 

Final Thoughts

bullet

Always try to be objective when marking. You may not obtain the most objective view by marking immediately after the game.

bullet

Judge the performance over the whole game. Don’t be too influenced by one particular incident.

bullet

Don’t mark the Referee down unfairly because your team was unlucky and lost the game or some disciplinary action was taken against your players.